Adding New BIP Editors
Posted by Matt Corallo
Apr 21, 2024/23:01 UTC
The discussion about appointing new BIP (Bitcoin Improvement Proposal) editors has raised several points of contention and clarity among participants in the Bitcoin Development Mailing List. A significant concern highlighted by some members is the perceived lack of time commitment from Roasbeef, suggesting that he may not be suitable for the role of a BIP editor. This viewpoint underscores the importance of dedication and availability in managing responsibilities that come with editing technical proposals within the Bitcoin community.
Further analysis reveals a preference for individuals who have demonstrated a long-term involvement and deep understanding of Bitcoin's technical language and editing standards. Specifically, Kanzure and Murch are identified as fitting candidates due to their extensive contributions and proven track records. Kanzure has been acknowledged for his comprehensive history of Bitcoin technical transcriptions, which illustrates a thorough engagement with the subject matter. Similarly, Murch's contributions, especially evident through his work on Stack Exchange and the detailed nomenclature BIP available at GitHub, further solidify his standing as a knowledgeable and capable figure within the Bitcoin technical community.
These discussions and evaluations highlight a critical aspect of the selection process for BIP editors - the necessity for candidates to have both a deep-seated knowledge of Bitcoin technology and a commitment to maintaining the high standards required for the role. The objections raised against the inclusion of other suggested names in the list of potential BIP editors emphasize the community's priority for quality and reliability in its leadership roles, aiming to ensure that chosen individuals are best suited to guide and refine the development of Bitcoin's technical infrastructure.
TLDR
Join Our Newsletter
We’ll email you summaries of the latest discussions from authoritative bitcoin sources, like bitcoin-dev, lightning-dev, and Delving Bitcoin.
Explore all Products
We'd love to hear your feedback on this project?
Give Feedback