lightning-dev

Lightning, the death of BIP62, and Segregated Witness

Lightning, the death of BIP62, and Segregated Witness

Original Postby Peter Todd

Posted on: November 22, 2015 20:24 UTC

Tadge Dryja has written about BIP62, which addresses multiple vectors for txid malleability and 3rd party malleability.

However, it does not help in the context of lightning channel creation because ECDSA sigs are inherently malleable. The needed functionality is to reliably spend from unconfirmed transactions. Segregated witness can accomplish that but it is a large hard-fork change. Sighash_noinput can also accomplish that, and it is not a hard fork change. It is generally difficult to come up with features that absolutely must be implemented as hard fork changes.