Posted by Antoine Riard
Jun 3, 2026/01:05 UTC
Antoine's email to Jeremy addresses a specific technical aspect of transaction validity within a Bitcoin development context. He clarifies that the idea under discussion does not involve removing the "seam" in the validity space entirely, but rather narrowing it down to a more defined structure. This implies that despite the adjustments, second-layer clients would still need to perform checks to prevent transactions that might violate this refined structure. Antoine expresses skepticism about whether this adjustment represents a significant improvement over the existing proposals.
Additionally, Antoine touches on a broader philosophical issue within Bitcoin development. He criticizes what he perceives as a shift away from Bitcoin’s foundational principle of delivering a trust-minimized security model. He suggests that recent discussions or proposals might be leaning towards a different approach which he refers to somewhat critically as a "trust-sama philosophy."
This summary captures the key points discussed in Antoine's correspondence without delving into personal sign-offs or contextual introductions, focusing solely on the technical and philosophical content presented.
Thread Summary (17 replies)
Jun 1 - Jun 29, 2026
18 messages • 17 replies
TLDR
We’ll email you summaries of the latest discussions from high signal bitcoin sources, like bitcoin-dev, lightning-dev, and Delving Bitcoin.
We'd love to hear your feedback on this project.
Give Feedback