bitcoin-dev

Hardforking Bitcoin to SLH-DSA (Future Proofing)

Hardforking Bitcoin to SLH-DSA (Future Proofing)

Original Postby scott beeker

Posted on: October 17, 2024 00:45 UTC

The consideration of transitioning Bitcoin to a post-quantum cryptographic algorithm such as SLH-DSA (Stateless Hash-Based Digital Signature Algorithm) stems from the growing concern over potential threats posed by quantum computing.

This transition is seen as crucial for safeguarding Bitcoin against the capabilities of quantum computers, which could eventually break the cryptocurrency's current elliptic curve cryptography. Implementing SLH-DSA would represent a significant shift from Bitcoin's existing Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA), necessitating profound modifications to its core protocol.

One of the critical challenges in adopting SLH-DSA lies in managing the increased key and signature sizes. Unlike ECDSA's relatively small signature sizes, SLH-DSA's signatures are considerably larger, which would have substantial implications for Bitcoin's block size, transaction throughput, and overall network bandwidth requirements. These changes would not only affect the storage and processing capacities required for operating Bitcoin nodes but could also lead to higher transaction fees due to the increased amount of blockchain space each transaction would occupy.

Moreover, the transition to SLH-DSA involves technical hurdles and consensus challenges. A hard fork of the Bitcoin network would be necessary, requiring broad agreement among stakeholders such as miners, node operators, and users. Ensuring backward compatibility would also be vital, potentially involving a period where both ECDSA and SLH-DSA signatures are accepted to facilitate a smoother migration for users. Additionally, all Bitcoin wallet software would need updates to accommodate the new signature scheme, including adjustments in key generation, signing, and verification processes.

Despite these challenges, moving to SLH-DSA offers significant benefits, primarily providing resistance to quantum computing attacks. This ensures the long-term security of the Bitcoin network. SLH-DSA's reliance on the well-understood security mechanisms of hash functions positions it as a conservative yet robust choice for post-quantum cryptography.

However, the transition process carries potential drawbacks, including the risk of increased centralization due to the heightened resource demands on node operators and the complexity of executing such a comprehensive change without introducing new vulnerabilities. Therefore, while the shift to SLH-DSA is technically feasible, it requires careful planning, extensive testing, and widespread community support. As advancements in quantum computing continue, the urgency and relevance of this discussion within the Bitcoin community are expected to grow. For further details and technical insights into this topic, resources such as Trail of Bits Blog, SLH-DSA GitHub Repository, Latacora Blog on Post-Quantum Cryptography, and an article on quantum computing's breakthroughs in breaking RSA encryption (CSO Online) provide valuable information.