Your daily summary

Recent discussions within the Bitcoin development community have focused on various proposals and disagreements among its members. Moonsettler highlighted the need for better organization and visibility of active proposals such as CovTools, LNhance, and C3PO to enhance community engagement and awareness, acknowledging a missed opportunity in the "Covenant Beauty Contest" for proposal presentation (source). Matt Corallo's approach to implementing changes in blockchain technology through soft forks, specifically addressing quantum resistance without new address formats, indicates a shift in strategy to secure the blockchain's future. This proposal includes exploring hash-based signatures and achieving community consensus on the adoption of such technologies, with a detailed plan for implementation and documentation laid out for community feedback (source).

In a separate vein, Antoine Riard announced his intention to take legal action against Matthew Corallo, stemming from a profound disagreement over governance and respect within open-source software (OSS) projects. This dispute, arising from their collaboration on the rust-lightning project, highlights the tensions that can occur between contributors in the OSS community. Riard's move towards litigation emphasizes the need for a more collaborative and respectful approach in OSS development, aiming to set a precedent on how decentralization and contribution are interpreted and managed within such projects (source).

Filter by List

Active Discussions 🔥

delvingbitcoin

Workgroup lifecycle

7 replies

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

MentalNomad, ariard+1 other

  • The cluster mempool working group was initially private, starting November 1, 2023.
  • Discussions were made public on November 30, 2023, to share insights without new members.
  • The group disbanded after its project became a priority for Bitcoin Core 28.0, documenting the process on February 22, 2024.

Today in Bitcoin/LN History

23 replies

Posted January 16, 2024 17:28 UTC

Authored by

t-bast

Involving

Greg Sanders, ajtowns+4 others

  • The proposal seeks to optimize lightning transactions using v3 transactions and ephemeral anchors.
  • It suggests simplifying commitment transactions and decoupling on-chain fees from off-chain funds.
  • Transition strategies include non-disruptive upgrade paths, pending formalization of proposals.

All Activity

6 replies

Posted January 16, 2025 18:43 UTC

Authored by

ismaelsadeeq

Involving

everythingSats , xBC +1 other

The recent scrutiny of F2Pool's block weight statistics unveiled discrepancies likely stemming from a mix-up in compiling data, leading to confusion between the minimum block weight and coinbase weight. A detailed examination pointed towards an anomaly in F2Pool's management of block weights, particularly after the introduction of a Bitcoin Core update GitHub that established a minimal reserved block weight.


3 replies

Posted January 15, 2025 23:37 UTC

Authored by

cooltexture

Involving

sjors , GaloisField2718

The discussion addresses the complexities of managing blockchain data storage, with a focus on the Bitcoin network. It explores the technical challenges associated with data pruning, particularly the removal of witness data from blocks once their validity is confirmed.


8 replies

Posted January 14, 2025 14:38 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

instagibbs , rijndael +3 others

Within the realm of blockchain and cryptocurrency, discussions around optimizing transaction settlement processes are critical. A notable proposal by Ademan for multi-party penalty-optional rebindable channels offers an innovative approach to improve the efficiency of these settlements.


7 replies

Posted January 13, 2025 08:47 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

ariard , MentalNomad +1 other

The shift towards a Working Groups model within the Bitcoin Core community represents a significant evolution in how projects are organized and reviewed, as seen with the implementation of the wg-cluster-mempool group. This new structure necessitates a reevaluation of the lifecycle of working groups to enhance accessibility and reduce entry barriers for interested parties.


3 replies

Posted January 13, 2025 00:00 UTC

Authored by

moonsettler

Involving

AntoineP

The discussion revolves around the technical nuances of implementing changes within Bitcoin Core's scripting mechanism, particularly concerning script flags. These flags are integral to instructing the script interpreter on the validation checks to be performed but are not deemed consensus critical.


4 replies

Posted January 11, 2025 22:13 UTC

Authored by

cryptoquick

Involving

conduition , conduition

The discussion emphasizes advancements in quantum-resistant cryptographic approaches for Bitcoin, moving beyond DASK to potentially more achievable solutions. Matt Corallo's proposal, detailed in a post on the Bitcoin developer's mailing list, suggests disabling key-spending on P2TR addresses and utilizing one of the OP_SUCCESS opcodes reserved by BIP342.


2 replies

Posted January 10, 2025 00:46 UTC

Authored by

rustyrussell

Involving

ariard , ariard

The email discusses a dispute between two individuals deeply involved in the rust-lightning project, highlighting a broader conflict within the open-source community. On one side is a person who perceives himself as a benevolent dictator of the projects he contributes to, expecting obedience and silence from other contributors.


54 replies

Posted January 9, 2025 11:16 UTC

Authored by

Fi

Involving

plebhash , marathongary +3 others

The complexity of implementing the share index and returning it to miners has been identified as a significant challenge, particularly due to the difficulty in ensuring both correctness and efficiency. The primary concern revolves around the necessity of this feature, especially when its main utility, preventing dishonesty about share indexes in slices, might be redundant given that the path provides sufficient information to determine the index of a leaf.


34 replies

Posted January 8, 2025 19:26 UTC

Authored by

EthnTuttle

Involving

davidcaseria , bytes +8 others

Exploring the future of cryptocurrency mining and payouts, a comprehensive discussion unfolds around the implementation of innovative protocols and systems designed to enhance the efficiency, security, and fairness of mining operations. At the core of this exploration is the development of mechanisms that facilitate the authentication of mining efforts and the distribution of rewards in a manner that addresses both current challenges and anticipates future needs within the digital currency space.

One significant proposal focuses on integrating the Blind Diffie-Hellman key exchange mechanism into the Stratum v2 Protocol as an extension, aiming to improve privacy and auditability, especially for small payouts.


33 replies

Posted January 8, 2025 18:05 UTC

Authored by

sjors

Involving

zawy , AntoineP +5 others

The discourse on blockchain technology and Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) illuminates the intricacies of managing block times and the mining difficulty adjustment mechanism. Concerns have been raised regarding the calculation method used for adjusting mining difficulty, which inadvertently might lead to an imbalance affecting network stability.


62 replies

Posted January 7, 2025 15:24 UTC

Authored by

AntoineP

Involving

bytes , sjors +11 others

The Great Consensus Cleanup proposal by Matt Corallo offers a comprehensive review and suggests modifications to address various inefficiencies and vulnerabilities within the Bitcoin protocol. This initiative covers several key areas, aiming to enhance network security and performance while inviting community engagement in refining and implementing these changes.

A primary focus of the proposal is the timewarp vulnerability, which poses a risk to network stability by allowing for artificial manipulation of mining difficulty.


3 replies

Posted January 7, 2025 14:20 UTC

Authored by

cdecker

Involving

ajtowns, instagibbs

The discussion revolves around the effectiveness and potential countermeasures against specific types of attacks on blockchain transaction finalization. One such attack involves stalling transactions through a method similar to replacement cycling, where an attacker submits bids to delay transactions but is limited by the blockchain's structure to one bid per block without prior knowledge of the mempool.


11 replies

Posted January 7, 2025 13:40 UTC

Authored by

mcelrath

Involving

evoskuil , harding +4 others

The email discussions delve into the intricacies of managing transactions within decentralized networks, specifically focusing on Braidpool's approach to transaction handling and block template generation. The primary aim is to enhance block validation and transmission efficiency by adopting a deterministic block template strategy, which eliminates redundancies in the transaction validation process.


7 replies

Posted January 7, 2025 12:37 UTC

Authored by

sipa

Involving

hebasto , lorbax +1 other

The exploration of optimizing transaction clusters within cryptocurrency networks focuses on effectively processing transactions by employing efficient linearization algorithms. These algorithms prioritize transactions based on fee rates while maintaining topological order, occasionally using post-processing techniques to refine the outcomes.


2 replies

Posted January 7, 2025 01:07 UTC

Authored by

ademan

Involving

instagibbs, ariard

The concept of a "punishable Eltoo" in multi-party settings has been previously explored by Lloyd Fournier and others, focusing on enhancing the Eltoo protocol with mechanisms that penalize dishonest behavior while aiming for a trustless design. This approach attempts to tackle the challenges inherent in multi-party constructions across the Bitcoin network, regardless of the security model employed.


Posted January 6, 2025 20:20 UTC

Authored by

mcelrath

The challenge revolves around developing specific covenant proposals to manage transactions within a Bitcoin mining pool constructively and securely. The primary objective is to utilize a covenant-based solution to ensure accurate and theft-proof payouts without requiring custody, aligning with a "can't-be-evil" philosophy.


17 replies

Posted January 6, 2025 16:45 UTC

Authored by

zawy

Involving

ProofOfKeags , harding +6 others

The discussion on improving Byzantine fault tolerance in digital currencies through the use of moderately hard puzzles highlights a novel approach to maintaining transaction integrity and security without revealing participant identities. This method, critical for enhancing blockchain robustness against attacks while preserving user anonymity, balances security needs against computational resource considerations.


7 replies

Posted January 5, 2025 09:34 UTC

Authored by

instagibbs

Involving

JeremyRubin , cguida +3 others

The concept of singletons and their application in blockchain technology presents a fascinating exploration into enhancing transactional integrity and efficiency. The notion, as discussed by @rijndael, revolves around the implementation of CAT (Chia Asset Token) in creating a standard token ecosystem, where the singleton emerges as a crucial element when the token aspects are stripped away.


11 replies

Posted January 4, 2025 15:51 UTC

Authored by

JeremyRubin

Involving

harding , ariard +3 others

The dynamic nature of Bitcoin and cryptocurrency innovation is marked by the frequent introduction and discontinuation of products. Each year, numerous Bitcoin-related products are launched with the hope of securing a sustainable user base, while others are phased out due to insufficient support.


10 replies

Posted January 3, 2025 21:44 UTC

Authored by

moonsettler

Involving

ProofOfKeags , harding +4 others

The discourse on programming, particularly in the context of Bitcoin's development, reflects a nuanced understanding of the balance between expressiveness and safety. The comparison between Bitcoin and Ethereum serves as a cautionary tale; Ethereum's maximally expressive contracts come with their own set of challenges, prompting a more measured approach for Bitcoin.


19 replies

Posted January 3, 2025 08:27 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

bytes , AdamISZ +5 others

The effectiveness and utility of statistics in soft fork testing, particularly concerning signet bots and their impact on OP_CAT supporters advocating for mainnet activation, form a central theme in recent discussions among developers. The Bitcoin Wiki serves as a platform where various rationales and examples are cited, highlighting the divide in community opinion regarding the implementation strategies of soft forks.


Posted January 2, 2025 23:23 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

The data provided highlights the trajectory of daily logged-in user visits to the delving website over a two-year period, specifically from January 2023 to December 2024. The figures show a progressive increase in site traffic, starting with 22 visits in January 2023 and experiencing significant growth to reach 1315 visits by December 2024.


2 replies

Posted December 30, 2024 15:15 UTC

Authored by

securitybrahh

Involving

HubertusVIE , moonsettler

The discussion sheds light on the critical challenges and potential pathways for Bitcoin and Monero in adapting to a future that might be influenced significantly by quantum computing. The narrative emphasizes that current cryptographic practices underpinning these cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin's reliance on Taproot Schnorr signature aggregation and Monero's privacy and security mechanisms, are not inherently quantum-resistant.


Posted December 28, 2024 16:08 UTC

Authored by

Pioneer775

The Armenian Crypto Project (ARMCP) has emerged as a pivotal initiative aimed at integrating cryptocurrencies and blockchain technologies into the daily transactions of both private investors and large financial institutions. This project addresses two primary obstacles hindering the growth of cryptocurrencies: the absence of regulation and the complexities involved in their interaction with traditional financial systems.


5 replies

Posted December 23, 2024 15:09 UTC

Authored by

Chris_Stewart_

Involving

bytes , harding +1 other

Soft forks within the Bitcoin network are designed with the intent to tighten existing rules, introducing a level of confiscation risk that can be subtle yet significant, affecting various stakeholders, especially miners. This risk is particularly evident in instances such as Bitmain's resistance to the Segregated Witness (SegWit) proposal, attributed to concerns over losing the benefits of covertly using ASICBoost technology.


11 replies

Posted December 19, 2024 19:21 UTC

Authored by

JohnLaw

Involving

morehouse , harding +1 other

The revised paper, now available at https://github.com/JohnLaw2/ln-opr, introduces significant updates to the Offchain Payment Routing (OPR) protocol, focusing on speed and scalability enhancements while maintaining security analogues to the current Lightning protocol for small payments. By adhering to the protocol, parties aim to preserve their long-term reputation, which in turn prevents theft, illustrating a trust-based mechanism akin to traditional financial systems.


2 replies

Posted December 18, 2024 12:47 UTC

Authored by

harding

Involving

ariard , everythingSats

The introduction of an upper limit on accepted feerate in the Lightning Development Kit (LDK) signifies a crucial advancement in addressing vulnerabilities associated with "irrevocable fees." This move, initiated in 2021, aimed to counter the risks posed by excessive trimmed HTLCs and dust HTLC exposure. By setting a cap on the feerate from a channel counterparty, LDK enables a more straightforward calculation of msat denominated worst-case scenarios for dust HTLCs exposure under various conditions.


16 replies

Posted December 17, 2024 12:54 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

ZmnSCPxj , prozacchiwawa +6 others

The email discussion begins with a clarification on the use of the >s operator in programming, highlighting its application for checking lexicographical order among elements. The conversation then transitions into a playful suggestion for naming a new programming language "Thcript," which cleverly references both scripting capabilities and a nod to Lisp's syntactic characteristics.


2 replies

Posted December 16, 2024 13:14 UTC

Authored by

halseth

Involving

AdamISZ , salvatoshi

The discussion revolves around the utilization of OP_CAT and covenants within the context of blockchain technology, specifically focusing on their applications in creating vector commitments and executing protocols as arbitrary state machines across multiple Unspent Transaction Outputs (UTXOs). The usage of OP_CAT, although primarily for vector commitments that facilitate Merkle proof checking, highlights its interchangeable nature with other opcodes like OP_PAIRCOMMIT/VECTORCOMMIT.


3 replies

Posted December 14, 2024 17:51 UTC

Authored by

QbitsCode

Involving

cryptoquick , QbitsCode

The recent update to the repository has introduced significant enhancements to Bitcoin's security by integrating both cryptographic groups, Group 1 and Group 2, alongside updates to the PQC manager and the addition of suitable tests. This integration is aimed at bolstering Bitcoin's defenses against quantum computing threats.


1 reply

Posted December 9, 2024 15:11 UTC

Authored by

ariard

Involving

ariard

The recent discovery of vulnerabilities within Bitcoin's transaction-relay rules has sparked considerable debate and concern. A detailed report, which can be found at this link, offers an in-depth examination of the issues at hand, revealing their broad implications for a variety of Bitcoin applications, notably including the Lightning Network.


1 reply

Posted December 8, 2024 16:55 UTC

Authored by

sCryptts

Involving

40000bytes

The development of a smart contract that leverages OP_CAT for creating a sidechain covenant marks a significant leap in blockchain technology, offering a pathway to integrating sidechains with Bitcoin without the need for major protocol upgrades like those proposed in BIP300. This smart contract enables independent blockchains, or sidechains, to be pegged to Bitcoin, facilitating the transfer of BTC between the mainchain and these sidechains.


21 replies

Posted December 7, 2024 17:22 UTC

Authored by

jungly

Involving

marathongary , mcelrath +2 others

The discussion centers on the innovative approach to decentralized mining pools through Radpool, aiming to address the challenges posed by traditional centralized mining pools. Radpool's model involves a network of Mining Service Providers (MSPs) that decentralizes block template generation, offering a solution to combat centralization in the mining sector.


45 replies

Posted December 6, 2024 17:27 UTC

Authored by

AntoineP

Involving

instagibbs , andrewtoth +8 others

The recent discussions and analyses concerning blockchain synchronization processes, notably between Libbitcoin and Bitcoin Core, offer profound insights into the architectural and operational efficiencies intrinsic to different implementations. Eric Voskuil's comparison, which positions Libbitcoin's Initial Block Download (IBD) performance as significantly superior to that of Bitcoin Core—allegedly up to 15 times faster when utilizing options akin to -assumevalid—sheds light on the nuanced methodologies underpinning this enhanced capability.


14 replies

Posted December 6, 2024 14:31 UTC

Authored by

sjors

Involving

evoskuil , ajtowns +3 others

The discussion delves into the complexities of blockchain validation processes, particularly focusing on the challenges and potential strategies for managing blocks that are expensive or time-consuming to validate. A key point is the decision-making process miners undergo when presented with a new block, weighing whether to build upon it or continue mining on the previous tip based on its validity.


29 replies

Posted December 4, 2024 14:33 UTC

Authored by

salvatoshi

Involving

sipa , josibake +7 others

The dialogue on enhancing wallet policies and descriptors in cryptocurrency transactions emphasizes the need for standardizing the implementation of unspendable keys, particularly within the context of taproot technology. The primary challenge lies in formulating a system where extended public keys (xpubs) can be standardized across both descriptors and wallet policies without compromising security or functionality.


3 replies

Posted December 2, 2024 16:11 UTC

Authored by

ZmnSCPxj

Involving

renepickhardt , ZmnSCPxj

The discussion centers around the critical need for plugin software within the Lightning Network to independently monitor unilateral exits from channel factories on the blockchain. This requirement stems from the fact that even if the factory layer closes and channels are published directly on-chain, they can still operate independently.


6 replies

Posted December 1, 2024 19:36 UTC

Authored by

mpch

Involving

instagibbs , jonas +2 others

The conversation begins with a focus on the experimentation with replacement cycling using Warnet, delving into prior efforts and significant refactors led by Jonas. This exploration is rooted in Ariard's development of a replacement cycling example, detailed through GitHub links to Warnet Pull Request 422 and Warnet Pull Request 373.


Posted November 30, 2024 09:35 UTC

Authored by

sCrypt-ts

In a collaborative effort between sCrypt and StarkWare, a demo bridge covenant on Bitcoin has been created to demonstrate the potential for a production-grade bridge connecting the Bitcoin blockchain to the Starknet Layer 2 network. This bridge employs a sophisticated method for managing deposit and withdrawal requests by batching them into a single transaction, thus updating the bridge's state efficiently.


delvingbitcoin

Feature Request

Posted November 27, 2024 14:46 UTC

Authored by

dexizer

Enhancing Bitcoin's security and versatility is paramount for its continued adoption and trustworthiness in the digital economy. The proposed improvements target four critical areas that, once addressed, could significantly bolster Bitcoin's infrastructure against various attacks while introducing new functionalities that expand its use cases.

The first area of improvement focuses on mitigating vulnerabilities associated with Dust/Dusting/Vector76/Double Spend attacks.


1 reply

Posted November 25, 2024 20:18 UTC

Authored by

ZmnSCPxj

Involving

ZmnSCPxj

The SuperScalar mechanism addresses the Last-Mile Problem for Bitcoin users on the Lightning Network, facilitating the acquisition of incoming liquidity without high blockchain operation costs. This innovative approach leverages a combination of Decker-Wattenhofer decrementing-nSequence offchain mechanisms, timeout trees, pseudo-Spilman channel factories, and laddering within a structure known as the SuperScalar construction.


1 reply

Posted November 25, 2024 19:06 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Involving

instagibbs

The concept of Flexible Coin Earmarks is introduced as an innovative approach to manage the distribution and utilization of a single coin's value across various purposes, termed "earmarks". This system allows for the independent update or exercise of these earmarks without altering the coin's overall balance or necessitating its division into smaller units.


18 replies

Posted November 24, 2024 15:13 UTC

Authored by

reardencode

Involving

michaelfolkson , instagibbs +8 others

The discussion around the capabilities and integration of new opcodes, specifically CTV (CheckTemplateVerify) and CSFS (CheckSequenceVerifyFromStack), into Bitcoin's protocol highlights ongoing efforts to enhance its scripting and transactional flexibility. The introduction of OP_PAIRCOMMIT (PC) alongside these opcodes marks a significant advancement in Bitcoin scripting, expanding the LNhance opcode family and facilitating the development of more complex and secure transactional channels.


12 replies

Posted November 23, 2024 15:47 UTC

Authored by

moonsettler

Involving

bytes , ajtowns +1 other

LNhance aims to enhance the scalability and efficiency of timeout tree and covenant pool constructions while enabling LN-Symmetry, previously known as eltoo. The introduction of IKEY facilitates access to the internal public key from the control block, primarily in a lightning channel scenario, allowing for cooperative closes on the taproot keypath.


5 replies

Posted November 21, 2024 15:10 UTC

Authored by

renepickhardt

Involving

ajtowns , sorukumar +1 other

In recent discussions, the focus on managing liquidity within payment channels has highlighted several key areas of concern and interest, particularly in relation to the Lightning Network's operational dynamics. The concept of channel depletion and its implications for network topology and fee management have been central to these explorations.


2 replies

Posted November 21, 2024 15:00 UTC

Authored by

ellemouton

Involving

harding , t-bast

The recent discussions and feedback surrounding the proposed updates to a specific protocol, as outlined in a GitHub proposal (this link), highlight the community's commitment to refining and advancing the project. The suggestions put forth for consideration primarily concern the enhancement of message structuring, particularly through the adoption of a Pure Type-Length-Value (TLV) format for new messages.


Posted November 13, 2024 08:07 UTC

Authored by

ajtowns

Jonas Nick recently highlighted an innovative application of WOTS+ (Winternitz One-Time Signature Plus) using expanded script opcodes proposed for the GSR project, showcasing a method for generating and verifying signatures within Bitcoin transactions. This method involves creating a WOTS+ secret/public key pair, which then facilitates the generation of a large script encoding the public key, seed, and randomizers.


4 replies

Posted November 12, 2024 00:26 UTC

Authored by

andyschroder

Involving

accumulator , andyschroder

The recent discussions and developments around BOLT12 have introduced innovative concepts aimed at enhancing the blockchain ecosystem's efficiency and security. Among these, the notion of "Bundled Payments" stands out as a pivotal addition.


1 reply

Posted November 6, 2024 19:16 UTC

Authored by

ismaelsadeeq

Involving

murch

The discussion opens with a query about the rationale behind distinguishing transactions for fee prediction purposes based on whether they have been confirmed or not. It suggests considering transactions received in the last 10 minutes as a benchmark for competition, implying a more dynamic approach to predicting transaction fees.

The core of the analysis evaluates the effectiveness of various fee rate forecasters over 1293 blocks, from block 848920 to 850213.


Posted November 5, 2024 11:57 UTC

Authored by

cndolo

In a recent exploration of the Lightning Network's (LN) susceptibility to censorship by network-level adversaries, such as Autonomous Systems (AS), significant findings were presented that shine a light on potential vulnerabilities within this decentralized payment system. The research delves into how privacy attacks leverage the identifiability of peer-to-peer messages through TCP headers, despite encryption.


Posted November 4, 2024 10:50 UTC

Authored by

fanquake

Bitcoin Core version 27.2 has been officially released, available for download from the specified source or via BitTorrent. This update comes with a variety of fixes and improvements aimed at enhancing the overall performance and user experience.


;
Bitcoin Logo

TLDR

Join Our Newsletter

We’ll email you summaries of the latest discussions from authoritative bitcoin sources, like bitcoin-dev, lightning-dev, and Delving Bitcoin.

Explore all Products

ChatBTC imageBitcoin searchBitcoin TranscriptsSaving SatoshiBitcoin Transcripts Review
Built with 🧡 by the Bitcoin Dev Project
View our public visitor count

We'd love to hear your feedback on this project?

Give Feedback