Ecash TIDES using Cashu and Stratum v2

The proposal in question is critiqued for being overly complex for its intended goal, which appears to be the facilitation of payouts using lightning or e-cash mechanisms. The critic suggests that for accomplishing just the payout objective, there's no necessity to link shares directly to e-cash or introduce any complex schemes. This implies a straightforward use of digital payment systems could suffice for distributing earnings without complicating the process by integrating shares and e-cash.

Furthermore, the discussion opens up to a broader perspective by considering the potential benefits of making pool shares a tradable asset through the use of e-cash. This proposition hints at an expanded goal beyond simple payout mechanisms, suggesting that if the aim includes creating a market for pool shares, employing e-cash might offer significant advantages. This could imply an innovative approach to enhancing liquidity and accessibility for investors in the pool, potentially transforming how shares are traded and owned.