Posted by andrewtoth
Feb 2, 2026/17:58 UTC
The discussion centers around the effectiveness and goals of two privacy-enhancing technologies in cryptocurrency transactions: Dandelion and private broadcast. Both aim to sever the link between a transaction and the originator's IP or persistent Tor/I2P address, though they approach this goal differently.
Dandelion is highlighted for its ability to enhance transaction relay privacy across the entire network. This method necessitates multiple hops and relies on the honesty of other nodes throughout these hops to successfully obscure the transaction's origin. The process is more comprehensive as it involves the entire network in the privacy mechanism.
On the other hand, private broadcast focuses on improving privacy at the initial stage of the transaction relay—specifically, the first hop. If a transaction is initiated through a private broadcast, it addresses the primary goal of disassociating the transaction from the originator's IP address or persistent address. However, this method is seen as more limited in scope compared to Dandelion, as it primarily enhances privacy at the starting point of the transaction relay without involving the entire network in the privacy effort.
The conversation reflects a debate on the relative merits and limitations of each approach. While both aim to achieve similar outcomes in terms of privacy, their mechanisms and scopes of impact vary, leading to differing perspectives on their overall effectiveness and areas of improvement.
Thread Summary (15 replies)
Jan 25 - Feb 8, 2026
16 messages
TLDR
We’ll email you summaries of the latest discussions from high signal bitcoin sources, like bitcoin-dev, lightning-dev, and Delving Bitcoin.
We'd love to hear your feedback on this project.
Give Feedback